Saturday, Jun 22 2013 08:00 PM

Local farmers worry about finding enough farmworkers

  1. 1 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    Several signs seeking farmworkers are posted on a bulletin board outside the Weedpatch Market. According to agriculture labor workers, many signs are posted at other markets and meeting places in the Lamont area. With grape harvest season still to come, many are anticipating labor shortages.

    click to expand click to collapse
  2. 2 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    The pay for harvesting a bucket of garlic ranges from $1.85 to $2.25 depending on supply and demand and the quality of the garlic. Many farmworkers prefer piecework as opposed to an hourly wage because they can make more money.

    click to expand click to collapse
  3. 3 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    "Treat the people right," advise Jesus and Beneranda Torres to Maximiliano Calihua, a 22-year-old crew boss just starting out. Jesus Torres is a labor contractor from Shafter who has been in business since the 1980s.

    click to expand click to collapse
  4. 4 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    Prisco Manzia came with a crew from Fresno to harvest garlic in a field southeast of Lamont. He left a minimum hourly wage job at a farm for piecework harvest where he could make some money. So he works in what could be described as a panic. A full bucket of garlic brings $1.85 an empty bucket brings nothing.

    click to expand click to collapse
  5. 5 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    There is a light moment as Pantaleon Vasquez is teased by other workers for receiving a bit of attention as he harvests garlic.

    click to expand click to collapse
  6. 6 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    As the workday continues in a field southeast of Lamont, workers who started harvesting garlic before the break of dawn have filled many bins. A man operating a large forklift does his job by stacking the bins two-high to get them ready for shipping.

    click to expand click to collapse
  7. 7 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    Workers harvesting garlic kick up a little dust as the sun begins to heat up the day. A steady sound of garlic dropping into buckets and sometimes Mexican music can be heard. The predawn start means their workday will end before the intense heat of the day arrives.

    click to expand click to collapse
  8. 8 of 8

    By Henry A. Barrios / The Californian

    Farmworkers harvest garlic near Lamont. Getting paid piecework means the faster you work, the more money you will earn. A shortage of workers is anticipated as the grape harvest season approaches.

    click to expand click to collapse
BY JOHN COX Californian staff writer

As a thousand acres of table grapes approach peak ripeness on his farm near Arvin, grower Rick Deckard says he's more concerned about fruit prices than he is about getting enough farmworkers to do the picking.

But that may soon change.

Related Info


A wide swath of California farms and ranches had trouble finding workers last summer despite higher pay and more recruiting, according to an unscientific poll by the California Farm Bureau Federation.

Sixty-one percent of the 794 farmers and ranchers who filled out survey responses between August and October reported being unable to find all the temporary workers they needed.

“That’s a pretty dramatic figure,” said Ben McFarland, executive director of the Kern County Farm Bureau.

“The supply’s not there and so people are paying higher than they’ve ever paid before to get people in the field to get the job done.”

The 2012 survey results are the most recent available; a 2013 follow-up is in the works.

Some farmers felt last year's shortage more acutely than others. A third of those reporting shortages indicated they were off by only 10 percent to 30 percent.

But a fifth of the farmers having trouble stated that they were understaffed by between about a third and half.

Nearly half of the survey respondents with trouble hiring were tree fruit growers; a quarter grow wine grapes.

The federation’s summary of farmer comments points to difficult conditions.

To cope with the labor shortage, farmers reportedly delayed work such as pruning and harvesting, used mechanization when possible and, in some cases, did not harvest part of their crop.

The survey summary said some farmers were planning to adjust their harvest schedule this year in order to stagger their region’s harvest times and reduce competition with nearby growers.

— Staff writer John Cox

Worries are mounting that the Central Valley's agricultural industry is falling ever shorter of the experienced labor it needs to bring its produce to market.

Despite wage increases and growing investment in automated harvesting equipment, ag trade groups say a worker shortage threatens farmers' profits. They fear that, over the long term, it will push them toward less labor-intensive crops that, in turn, will raise prices on fruit and vegetables that require experienced field workers.

"I think if we don't solve the problem, (consumers) are definitely going to see more expensive food and more imported food. And, you know, of course, the risk with imported food is that it's not grown to the same food safety standards as food grown in the United States," said Bill Phillimore, executive vice president of Paramount Farming Co.

But for all the urgency and the political pressure for legislation that could allow more farmworkers from Mexico, Deckard said he's not worried. He has already raised his wages by 4 percent to about $8.30 an hour and is considering additional incentives to attract the roughly 400 workers he needs to pick his grapes.

"I'm not too overly concerned at this point," said Deckard. "In two weeks, I might change my mind."

His relative confidence puts him in the minority, according to alarming survey results from the California Farm Bureau Federation. It said 61 percent of farmers surveyed experienced a shortage of temporary workers last year. Some reported that they opted not to harvest part or all of their crop because they lacked sufficient help.


Deckard is not alone in his skepticism. The United Farm Workers union maintains that there is no field labor shortage -- that calls continue to come in from people looking for work in the fields.

"The reality is, there are enough workers. They just don't have documents," UFW spokeswoman Maria Machuca said.

Sometimes, though, the people who show up for work do not measure up to traditional standards, said Bakersfield-area almond farmer Richard Enns.

"Not all these people that are doing these jobs are actually qualified to do them," he said.

Some of the reasons cited for California's farm labor shortage are recent developments, such as hiring in construction, a surge in immigration raids, Mexico's improving economy and violence along the U.S.-Mexican border. Other factors are longer-term, like Mexico's changing demographics, California's relatively high cost of living and growing demand for farm labor in Oregon and Washington.

The point is often made that the shortage is not borne equally among valley farmers -- that it's harder on grape and tree fruit farmers, for instance, than it is on nut growers whose pistachios and almonds don't require as much immediate, hands-on attention.


Some in the industry point to what they see as an obvious solution: Raise wages.

"The reality is, the farmworkers are not stupid. They make economic decisions in life. If there's a crop somewhere that pays decent money, they will go and do that work," said Guadalupe Sandoval, managing director of the roughly 50-member California Farm Labor Contractor Association.

Offering better pay can be difficult for farmers who grow crops with thin profit margins. Others have had little choice, such as members of the California Grape and Tree Fruit League, which this year reported raising wages by 10 percent to 15 percent to between $9 and $11 an hour.

The better solution, industry representatives said, is to pass an immigration reform bill like the one being debated in Washington, D.C.


Trade group leaders called on Central Valley congressmen, and specifically House Whip Kevin McCarthy, R-Bakersfield, to work out a bipartisan compromise on the bill co-authored and championed by Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Florida.

The bill being debated in the U.S. Senate, the Border Security, Economic Opportunity and Immigration Modernization Act of 2013, would provide a chance at citizenship for the nation's estimated 11 million immigrants here without authorization since the end of 2011. Specific provisions benefit agricultural workers and children of immigrants.

The bill proposes tougher border enforcement, including work on a border fence. It would also tighten workplace hiring rules by expanding use of an electronic employment eligibility system. If signed into law, it would be the nation's largest immigration overhaul in more than a quarter century.

"We need a legal and stable workforce," said Barry Bedwell, president of the grape and tree fruit association. "So, our No. 1 issue is immigration reform."

"It's going to be so important that leaders like Rep. McCarthy ... come up with a bill that can be reconciled ... with the Senate version."

In an email June 12, McCarthy declined to state his position on Rubio's bill but asserted the nation's immigration system is "broken" and getting worse. He emphasized the need to secure the border, enforce current laws and find "a real long-term solution to our immigration processes."

The president of the California Farm Bureau Federation, Paul Wenger, said the Rubio bill is not perfect but at least it has support from lawmakers in both parties.

"If we don't get this (reform) done by August, we better not even discuss it for six or seven years because it's not going to happen," Wenger said.

But even he wondered how much immigration reform will help farmers in the long term. He said in Mexico -- California's traditional source of farmworkers -- the overall population is aging and having smaller families. Even so, he asserted that immigration reform would help alleviate the labor shortage in the near term.

Sandoval, with the labor contractor association, is not so sure. Although he called immigration reform "better than what we have now," he predicted that such legislation would give immigrants career alternatives other than field work.

"They're going to go into anything but agriculture," he said. "It's hard to work and there are easier ways to work for a living."

He proposed a more radical solution: "I think you need to open up the border. I think you need to have more opportunities for more workers."


People on the front lines of the search for more farmworkers, the labor contractors themselves, said competition for experienced laborers has gotten tougher.

Wasco labor contractor Hugo Sanchez said many workers have found work in Washington, where wages are better and the cost of living is generally lower. What's more, he said, recent U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids have spooked the laborers that remain.

"I look for people and I look for people," he said, adding that "there won't be enough" workers for the grape harvest coming at the end of this month or early July.

Labor contractor Jesus Torres said the very fact that he has been bringing a crew from Fresno all the way to the Lamont area in recent weeks is evidence of the worsening farmworker shortage.

With more than three decades of experience in the industry, he said his farmer clients have helped somewhat by raising wages about 10 percent. But he agreed that a surge in immigration raids under the Obama administration have been a big deterrent.

He suggested fewer restrictions on who's allowed to work here.

"They come to work," he said of Mexican farmworkers. "They're hard workers who come to work."

Have something to share? Comment on this story
Today's Daily Deal
Daily Deal Image
The Nines Restaurant
50% off Dining at The Nines Restaurant 
  • Value
  • Savings
  • Bought
Buy Now